Thursday, December 15, 2011

The Secret Sisterhood Of Heartbreakers by Lynn Weingarten

Title: The Secret Sisterhood Of Heartbreakers
Author: Lynn Weingarten
Release date: December 27, 2011
Publisher: HarperTeen
Pages: 352
Source: Publisher

When her boyfriend breaks up with her on the first day of sophomore year, Lucy has no idea how she’s going to make it through homeroom, let alone the rest of her life. Enter three stunning girls with a magical offer Lucy can’t refuse. All she has to do is get a guy to fall in love with her in the next seven days, and then…break his heart and collect one of his brokenhearted tears. As the girls teach Lucy how to hook a guy (with the help of a little magic), she quickly discovers how far she is willing to go—and who she is willing to cross—to get what she wants.

I really wanted to like The Secret Sisterhood Of Heartbreakers.  I enjoyed Lynn Weingarten’s previous novel, Wherever Nina Lies, so I had high hopes for this one.  Sadly it fell short.

Lucy was my biggest problem.  She was whiny and immature.   She needed magic to get over a guy.  She couldn’t do it on her own because she wouldn’t stop fawning over him.  The whole book was pretty much just about getting him back.  Then there were Olivia, Liza, and Gil. I didn’t get the point of the heartbreakers.  They just made guys fall for them so they could break their hearts.  I found it cruel and pointless.  The only character I even remotely liked was Tristan and he didn’t have a very big role.  I wanted more of him.

I also didn’t get the plot.  Lucy had seven days to break a guys heart.  She instead spent the whole time trying to get Alex back.  The whole story was about Alex (who I didn’t even like.)

Overall, it was a unique story with lots of potential but I just did not enjoy it.  I will not give up on Lynn Weingarten’s future books though.

Rating:  C

Follow by Email


  1. Cialina at

    Oh geez, this is a bit disheartening to hear. I quite liked the trailer, but I don’t like the sound of the book AT ALL after reading your review. It does seem really mean and catty to just run around trying to break people’s hearts. I will have to rethink picking this one up.

  2. LoriStrongin

    Bummer this one was such a let down. The blurb sounded kind of interesting, but yeah, it sounds like the main character spends more time whining that actually being proactive in a plot line. I’m not a fan of those kinds of people in real life, and ditto for fictionalized ones.

    Thanks for the honest review!


  3. Christina Kit.

    I loved the sound of the club, but it’s too bad the characters didn’t support the awesome premise. The magic could’ve been cool.

    Lovely review 🙂

Leave a Reply